When it comes to American cuisine on Hatteras Island, it doesn't get more Hatteras Island than seafood. Tuna, mahi mahi, tilefish, blue crab, shrimp, oysters and more – prepared in ways ranging from broiled seafood platters to fried fish sandwiches – steal the spotlight on these restaurants menus. Of course, there’s plenty more than just seafood at these Hatteras restaurants. Sports bars, delis, burger joints, barbecue spots and grills delight an array of palates and tastes with sandwiches, burgers, salads, steaks and more. The majority of Hatteras restaurants offer dishes and create environments that diners of all ages can enjoy, with eateries perfect for grabbing a bite while hopping between activities as well as upscale spots for a special occasion.
Featured for Your Visit
Hatteras American & Family Oriented
47355 N.C. Highway 12, Buxton
Experience island cuisine and the vibrant and bold flavors of the tropics at Rusty's Surf and Turf on Hatteras Island. Rusty Midgett, the owner and chef, is a native of the island who gained valuable experience in some of Philadelphia's top restaurants. Inspired by his travels to surf destinations like the Caribbean, the Mexican Riviera and the Pacific Rim, Midgett creates creative and delicious dishes using fresh seafood and premium beef. The restaurant is adorned with colorful and cheerful local artwork and has a full bar that features North Carolina beers and handcrafted cocktails. Rusty's also offers a fun bar menu with appetizers. In the summer, dinner is served seven days a week, and off-season hours are available upon request. The restaurant is conveniently located between Natural Art Surf Shop and the ABC Store. Get ready to be surprised by the unique flavors and preparations at Rusty's Surf and Turf.
Experience island cuisine and the vibrant and bold flavors of the tropics at Rusty's Surf and Turf on Hatteras Island. Rusty Midgett, the owner and chef, is a native of the island who gained valuable experience in some of Philadelphia's top restaurants. Inspired by his travels to surf destinations like the Caribbean, the Mexican Riviera and the Pacific Rim, Midgett creates creative and delicious dishes...
read moreExperience island cuisine and the vibrant and bold flavors of the tropics at Rusty's Surf...
read more
Hatteras American & Family Oriented
Lisa’s, in business since 1986, is legendary on Hatteras Island. Everyone comes here for lunch or dinner to chow down on Italian favorites like hand-tossed pizza, calzones, lasagna, manicotti and spaghetti. Submarine sandwiches, wraps and burgers are also on the menu. The side dishes, including salads, fried mushrooms and broccoli, chicken wings and garlic cheese bread, are outstanding. Lisa's serves beer and wine, including nine...read more
Hatteras American & Family Oriented
There’s a constant flow of customers at this convenience store deli counter, so you know that’s a sign the food is delicious. The deli’s breakfast offerings include fresh-made biscuits and breakfast platters, breakfast sandwiches on croissants, muffins, bagels, toast or biscuits and more. For lunch you can get deli sandwiches, vegetables and french fries with daily specials available Monday through Friday. They also offer eight-,...read more
Hatteras American & Family Oriented
Looking for great food and live music with a waterfront view? It's ready for you in Rodanthe at Neptune's Kitchen and Dive Bar. They offer live music outdoors every week and serve cold beer, seafood platters, steamers, apps, sandwiches, entrees, a kids menu, dessert and more. From a burger or Philly cheesesteak to fish tacos and crabcake dinners to popcorn shrimp and grilled cheeses for...read more
Hatteras American & Family Oriented
Come to this Hatteras Island favorite for homemade Italian specialties – pizza on hand-tossed dough, calzones, spaghetti, pasta dishes, lasagna and subs – along with hamburgers and salads. Whatever you order, it’s guaranteed to be great. Nino’s has been serving meals on Hatteras Island for nearly four decades, so know you can trust that longevity. Lunch and dinner are served daily, and delivery is available. They serve beer...read more
Hatteras American & Family Oriented
Named for the orange trees that once grew on the property, Orange Blossom is a Hatteras Island favorite for breakfast. Everyone loves the Apple Uglies and the Meyer’s Rum Raisin Cinnamon Rolls, the double-dipped doughnuts and the pastries (the Apple Uglies and cinnamon rolls go fast, so get there early!). Orange Blossom offers just about any breakfast sandwich you could imagine, on biscuits, bagels, croissants,...read more
Hatteras American & Family Oriented
Pamlico Deli specializes in big, made-to-order, New York-style deli sandwiches and pre-prepared, authentic Italian takeout meals, all made with high-quality ingredients. A variety of sandwich options are on the menu, from a classic Reuben to the innovative Southern to a couple of vegetarian options. Charcuterie boards are available as well. Standouts at Pamlico Deli are the house-made marinara sauce, pasta dishes, cold salads, desserts and even fresh mozzarella, which...read more
Hatteras American & Family Oriented
Experience unique island and international cuisine at Pangea Tavern. From gourmet burgers to fresh seafood, Pangea has something for everyone’s taste buds. On Tuesdays Pangea Tavern features Tuesday Brewsday with all of their N.C. craft beers priced at only $3 per pint. Wednesdays are Wine Down Wednesdays with half-priced bottles of wine, and Thursdays are $1 Fresh Oysters, which are harvested from local waters. Saturday...read more
Hatteras American & Family Oriented
On the northern end of Avon next to OceanAir Sports, Po House is a casual waterfront restaurant with great views of the soundside activities and those amazing Pamlico Sound sunsets. Their creative cuisine incorporates a lot of local seafood; be sure to try their tasty seafood bisque, crab cakes, oyster po'boy, fish and chips, and daily specials made with the freshest catches. If you're not...read more
Hatteras American & Family Oriented
Pop’s is frequented by a lot of locals – a sure sign that the seafood meets local standards of excellence – and it’s a great place to have a real local experience. Across from Buxton Harbor, Pop’s specializes in steamed seafood, including shrimp, clams, oysters and crab legs. They also have more hearty fare, like burgers, subs, barbecue, seafood platters and a lot more. They’re open...read more
Hatteras American & Family Oriented
Established in 1978, Quarterdeck has been proudly serving the Hatteras Island community for 40 years! It's a locally owned, casual, family-oriented restaurant with soundside views. Quarterdeck serves lunch and specializes in seafood, seafood and more seafood (try the crab cakes and stuffed flounder), char-grilled steaks and several other options for landlubbers, and homemade desserts (their pies are some of the best on the island). You...read more
Hatteras American & Family Oriented
Sandbar and Grille is a longtime island favorite. It has a casual atmosphere, delicious food and an expansive view of Pamlico Sound and every sunset. Whether you’re in the mood for something as simple as a burger or something decadent like Shrimp and Crab Alfredo, the Sandbar has it. Homemade soups, salads, sandwiches, fresh local seafood, ribs, steaks, pastas – everything is good here. The...read more
Hatteras American & Family Oriented
Sheila's Carolina Kitchen is inside the clubhouse at Cape Hatteras KOA, but you do not have to be a guest of the KOA to enjoy it. They offer inexpensive, fast food for breakfast, lunch and dinner, including seafood, sandwiches, wraps, fish tacos, burgers, milkshakes and more. The breakfast menu is extensive and includes all the traditional favorites like omelettes, pancakes, biscuits & gravy, breakfast plates...read more
